Skip to content
Some links are advertising or affiliate links. How we make money
THRYV News

Independent reviews, guides and reporting.

Best Lists

News

Amica and Erie Insurance Top J.D. Power's 2026 Home Insurance Satisfaction Rankings

With homeowner and renter premiums under pressure, J.D. Power's annual study found insurers who communicate proactively are keeping customers happiest.

By THRYV Reviews Desk·Published September 22, 2026·Updated September 22, 2026·4 min read
Amica and Erie Insurance Top J.D. Power's 2026 Home Insurance Satisfaction Rankings
Best Lists · Illustration commissioned for THRYV. Photography is replaced with original imagery as each story is produced.

The takeaway

J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Home Insurance Study ranks Amica highest among homeowners insurers for a second straight year at 680 points out of 1,000, followed by Erie Insurance and Chubb. State Farm topped the renters insurance category. The study, based on over 17,000 policyholders, found affordability pressure is straining customer trust industrywide.

Amica topped J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Home Insurance Study for the second consecutive year, as the annual customer-satisfaction survey found homeowners increasingly worried about affordability even when they're happy with their insurer's service.

Top Homeowners Insurers (out of 1,000 points)

  1. Amica — 680
  2. Erie Insurance — 678
  3. Chubb — 676

Top Renters Insurers (out of 1,000 points)

  1. State Farm — 702
  2. Erie Insurance — 692
  3. Amica — 689

The study surveyed 17,191 homeowners and renters between July 2025 and July 2026, measuring satisfaction across policy offerings, price, billing, communication and claims handling.

Why Satisfaction Is Under Pressure

J.D. Power says the bigger story this year isn't any single insurer's score, but a broader affordability squeeze hitting homeowners as premiums climb alongside other household costs.

Homeowners are dealing with a broader affordability problem, not just an insurance premium problem. Because household costs are rising and insurance rates are under pressure, customers need carriers to explain what is changing, why it matters and what value they are getting in return. Carriers that communicate early, make service easy and help customers understand coverage are better positioned to keep homeowners who are facing increasing financial pressure.
Craig Martin, Executive Director, Insurance Intelligence, J.D. Power

If you're shopping for a policy

J.D. Power's rankings measure satisfaction, not price — it's still worth comparing quotes from multiple insurers, since premiums for identical coverage can vary significantly by carrier and location.

Sources

This article is original writing by THRYV. We link to primary reporting and official documents rather than reproducing them.

  1. 2026 U.S. Home Insurance StudyJ.D. Power

Why you can trust this article

Written and edited in-house by the THRYV Reviews Desk. We do not republish or reword agency copy, and we do not invent quotes, statistics, testimonials or ratings. Where figures move frequently, we point you to the primary release rather than printing a number that will be out of date. Advertising and affiliate partnerships have no influence on our reporting — see our editorial standards, fact-checking policy and affiliate disclosure. Spotted an error? Write to newsroom@thryv-news.com.

General information only. Not personalised financial, medical or legal advice.

Related reading

The THRYV Brief

The market in 5 minutes, weekday mornings

Plain-English analysis, the sources behind it, and what it changes for you. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. We never sell your email address.

Advertisement · Newsletter sponsorship600×120
Advertise with THRYV News — medium rectangle placement available

This position is available to a single sponsor per edition, is labelled in the email and on this page, and does not influence what the Brief covers.

Advertisement
Advertise with THRYV News — medium rectangle placement available